Owning a car dealership is an attractive business opportunity for entrepreneurs, offering potential for growth and profitability. As of 2024, there were approximately 17,392 car dealerships in the U.S., reflecting the increasing demand for new and used vehicles. Deciding between a franchised or independent dealership model is crucial for anyone looking to enter this competitive market.
Starting a car dealership requires choosing between two primary models: franchised and independent dealerships. Each model presents different business structures, investment requirements, and operational benefits. Understanding these differences is key to making the right decision for your long-term success as a dealership owner.
This article will explain the differences between franchised and independent dealerships, covering the business models, investment requirements, and operational benefits. This will help you decide which type works best for you as a future dealership owner.
Types of Car Dealers
Selecting franchised and independent dealership models for aspiring dealership owners significantly impacts your investment, business structure, and operational strategy. There are two main types of car dealerships:
Franchised Car Dealerships
Franchised car dealerships operate under agreements with specific vehicle manufacturers, giving owners the exclusive right to sell cars from that brand. These dealerships focus on selling new vehicles and certified pre-owned (CPO) cars with manufacturer-backed warranties.
For potential owners, franchised dealerships offer strong brand support and structured operations, though they require higher initial investments and adherence to manufacturer regulations.
Critical features of franchised dealerships are as follows:
- Exclusive Rights: They only sell cars from one manufacturer.
- Warranty Backing: Most new and CPO cars come with warranties directly from the manufacturer.
- Manufacturer Standards: Franchised dealerships are held to strict standards regarding customer service, vehicle condition, and pricing.
As a dealership owner, franchised dealerships ensure strong manufacturer support, providing structured training for your sales and service teams. This allows you to maintain brand loyalty and consistent customer service. However, this model limits the variety of brands you can offer, and you will need to align strictly with manufacturer standards.
Independent Car Dealerships
Independent car dealerships offer greater flexibility as they are not tied to any specific manufacturer. As an independent dealer, you can sell various used vehicles across multiple brands and sometimes even offer new cars through private imports. These dealerships typically require lower startup costs than franchised dealerships, but owners must manage inventory, pricing, and marketing without backing a large brand.
The following are the critical features of independent dealerships:
- Wider Variety: Independent dealers offer vehicles from multiple manufacturers, providing more choices.
- Flexible Pricing: Independent dealerships often have more flexible pricing, allowing owners to cater to a broad customer base and adjust prices based on market demands.
- Vehicle Condition: Cars sold at independent dealerships can sometimes come with third-party warranties, which increases customer trust and enhances your dealership’s reputation for reliability.
As a prospective owner, independent dealerships offer flexibility by allowing you to sell various brands and vehicle types, catering to a broad customer base. While independent dealerships don’t benefit from manufacturer-backed warranties, they provide more freedom in inventory selection and pricing strategy, which can be appealing if you want to focus on affordability and variety.
We now understand the fundamental differences between dealership types. Let’s examine the regulatory standards that govern dealership operations, as these regulations can significantly impact your business efficiency and long-term profitability.
Regulatory Standards
Franchised and independent dealerships are subject to different regulatory standards, which affect how they operate and provide services. As a franchised dealership owner, you must comply with strict manufacturer guidelines covering everything from showroom presentation to customer satisfaction. Independent dealership owners have more flexibility but must follow state and national trade laws. Awareness of these regulations is essential to ensure smooth operations and avoid legal complications. Here’s how regulatory oversight differs between franchised and independent dealerships.
Franchised Car Dealerships
Franchised dealerships must follow strict standards set by the manufacturer. These guidelines cover everything, from the showroom’s appearance to vehicle pricing. Franchises are subject to the following compliances:
- Regular Audits: Manufacturers conduct routine audits to ensure their dealerships meet performance benchmarks and uphold the brand’s reputation.
- Compliance with Service and Customer Satisfaction Standards: Franchised dealerships must maintain high service levels, often measured by customer satisfaction surveys provided by the manufacturer.
Franchised dealership owners must adhere to manufacturer regulations, which ensure consistent service and customer satisfaction across locations. However, these rules limit your flexibility in pricing and promotional strategies, which could impact your ability to adapt to market conditions.
Independent Car Dealerships
Independent car dealerships enjoy more flexibility but must follow local and national trade laws. Manufacturer guidelines don’t bind them, but many join an Independent Dealer Association (IDA), which sets industry standards and promotes ethical practices.
With regulatory standards setting the foundation for dealership operations, financing plays a significant role in vehicle sales. Let’s examine how the financing options differ between franchised and independent dealerships.
Financing Options
Financing plays a critical role in dealership operations, directly impacting your ability to purchase inventory and offer competitive loan options to customers. Franchised dealerships benefit from manufacturer-backed financing, allowing owners to provide low-interest loans that attract more qualified buyers. Independent dealerships, though reliant on in-house financing, can appeal to a broader range of customers, providing flexible terms that meet the needs of those with varying credit backgrounds.
Franchised Car Dealerships
As a franchised dealership owner, you’ll benefit from financing advantages through your manufacturer partnerships, such as access to low-interest loans, special promotions, and manufacturer-backed financing programs. Independent dealership owners, while lacking these manufacturer incentives, have more flexibility in offering in-house financing and serving customers with diverse credit backgrounds, making them a viable option for underserved markets.
- Low-Interest Loans: These dealerships often provide incentivized financing options through manufacturer-backed programs, such as low or zero-percent APR on new vehicles.
- Exclusive Deals: Franchised dealerships may offer cash rebates or special promotions during specific periods, incentivizing buyers to purchase new or certified pre-owned vehicles.
- Manufacturer Financing: As a dealership owner, you can offer favorable manufacturer-backed financing options, which can help attract customers with good credit and close more high-value sales.
Independent Car Dealerships
Independent dealerships provide financing, but the terms often need to be more favorable than those from franchised dealers. However, they tend to offer more flexible options, especially for buyers with poor or limited credit histories.
- Higher Interest Loans: Independent dealerships often offer higher interest loans, especially for used vehicles. These loans can be more accessible to buyers who might not qualify for manufacturer-backed financing.
- In-House Financing: Many independent dealerships offer in-house financing, meaning they directly finance vehicle purchases. This allows owners to provide flexible terms to customers and capture additional revenue through financing fees.
While the interest rates might be higher, independent dealerships can serve customers who need help from traditional lenders.
Now that we’ve covered the differences in financing options, let’s move on to how these dealerships differ in vehicle pricing and age. This is a critical factor in buyers’ decisions between franchised and independent dealerships.
Vehicle Pricing and Age
As a dealership owner, the type of vehicles you sell directly impacts your profit margins. Franchised dealerships focus on selling new or certified pre-owned (CPO) vehicles, which typically command higher prices, though they involve higher operating costs. Independent dealerships, by contrast, offer used cars, which require a lower initial investment and provide greater flexibility in inventory management.
Franchised Car Dealerships
Franchised dealerships mainly sell new cars and certified pre-owned (CPO) vehicles. These vehicles are often newer, include manufacturer warranties, and may have the latest features.
- Higher Prices: New vehicles cost more due to their advanced features and brand-new condition.
- Certified Pre-Owned: CPO vehicles undergo manufacturer inspections and certification, which can help dealership owners build trust with customers and justify higher price points for used cars.
Independent Car Dealerships
Independent dealerships primarily sell used vehicles, which allows owners to offer more affordable pricing. These dealerships can attract a broader customer base and provide greater flexibility in inventory and vehicle models, catering to diverse market demands.
- Lower Prices: Independent dealerships typically offer used vehicles at more competitive prices, allowing owners to attract a broader range of customers while maintaining higher margins on pre-owned vehicles.
- Older Models: You’ll find cars a few years old that are still in good condition
Now that we’ve covered pricing and the types of vehicles available, let’s examine the level of service and expertise you can expect from each type of dealership.
Also read: A Dealership’s Complete Guide to Vehicle Merchandising
Vehicle Service and Knowledge
Franchised and independent dealerships differ in how they manage vehicle service operations.
Franchised Car Dealerships
Franchised dealerships typically have manufacturer-trained technicians, which allows the dealership to provide specialized repairs and warranty services, adding value to their service department. Independent dealerships often partner with third-party repair shops, giving them more flexibility in service offerings but requiring additional efforts to manage external vendor relationships.
- Expert Technicians: Franchised dealerships employ manufacturer-trained technicians, allowing owners to provide specialized, high-quality services that reinforce brand trust and customer loyalty.
- Warranty Repairs: Only franchised dealerships can perform warranty repairs if your car is under warranty.
Independent Car Dealerships
Independent dealerships often partner with third-party mechanics for repairs and maintenance. While this offers more flexibility and lower overhead costs, it may also require additional efforts in managing service contracts and maintaining quality control across different vehicle brands.
- External Mechanics: Independent dealerships use third-party repair shops for vehicle servicing.
- General Knowledge: Mechanics at these shops work on various brands, providing less specialized expertise.
Now that we’ve explored the differences in pricing, vehicle age, and service, let’s examine how these dealerships differ in their vehicle selection.
Vehicle Selection
Regarding the variety of cars available, franchised and independent dealerships differ quite a bit.
Franchised Car Dealerships
Franchised dealerships offer a limited selection as they are tied to specific manufacturers. While this restricts the variety of brands, the dealership benefits from selling the latest models, which can cater to high-end customer demand.
- Limited Variety: You’ll mostly see vehicles from just one manufacturer.
- New Models: Franchised dealers usually have the latest models with the newest features and technology.
Independent Car Dealerships
Independent dealerships offer the advantage of stocking vehicles from multiple manufacturers. It allows owners to diversify their inventory and appeal to a broader customer base.
- More Variety: This variety helps owners adapt to changing market demands and customer preferences.
- Used Cars: Independent dealerships often focus on selling used vehicles, which gives owners greater flexibility in pricing and the ability to cater to a diverse customer base looking for affordable options.
Now that we’ve explored vehicle selection, let’s summarise the key differences between franchised and independent dealerships and understand which one might best fit your needs.
Also read: Automotive Industry Signage: Types, Benefits & Future Trends
Conclusion
Deciding between a franchised or independent dealership model hinges on your business objectives. Franchised dealerships offer the security of brand recognition and consistent manufacturer support, while independent dealerships allow you to tailor your operations and inventory based on market demands. Consider your investment capacity, long-term business goals, and market environment to choose the model for your dealership.
Here are the key points to help you decide.
Table: Franchised vs. Independent Dealerships
| Factor | Franchised Dealerships | Independent Dealerships |
| Vehicle Type | New and Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) | Mostly used cars |
| Price Range | Higher prices for new models | More affordable for used cars |
| Warranty | Manufacturer-backed warranty on new/CPO cars | Limited or third-party warranties |
| Financing Options | Low-interest loans, rebates, incentives | Higher interest, in-house financing for bad credit |
| Vehicle Selection | Limited to one brand | Wide variety from multiple brands |
| Service | Brand-specific service and expertise | General service, third-party mechanics |
If you’re considering owning a dealership, a franchised model offers stability, brand recognition, and support but comes with higher initial costs and less operational freedom. Independent dealerships provide more flexibility, lower startup costs, and the ability to tailor your business to local market demands, though they require more effort in managing operations without manufacturer backing. The best choice depends on your business goals, market conditions, and investment capacity.
Do you want to improve your dealership’s inventory display with professional visuals? Try Spyne’s AI-powered solutions for dealerships to elevate your business.
